In the Beginning...
Businesses
Churches
Citizens
City Services
Groups & Clubs
Parks & Recreation
Records &
Documents
Crimes, Deaths &
Disasters
Media &
Communications
Schools
Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio
History |
Mary Campbell
Kidnapping
Pennsylvania Gazette -
Bierce's Early Signs of
Ohio - Perrin's
History of Summit County -
Cherry's
The Portage Path

Mary Campbell Cave, located in Cuyahoga
Falls
within the boundaries of the Gorge Metropolitan Park, was reportedly an American
Indian camp site. The cave was created during the last 12,000 years when the
Cuyahoga
River was forced to carve a new path toward Lake Erie because it was blocked by
glacial debris. For many years it was known as Old Maid's Kitchen, until the
Daughters of the American Revolution renamed it Mary Campbell Cave.

In the summer of 1759, Mary Campbell, a young girl from Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania, was abducted by Delaware Indians and taken to an Indian camp in
Armstrong County, PA. She was rumored to have been adopted and raised as a
daughter by Chief Netawatwees
(totem of him on Front st. near Riverfront Park), whose village was located near present day
Cuyahoga
Falls, Ohio. In 1764, Colonel Henry Boquet, an
officer of the English army, liberated Mary and other white captives after the
French and Indian War ended. There is no known documentation of Mary living in
this particular area however.
It is apparent that when
Perrin was writing his version of the Campbell Kidnapping he had a copy of
Bierce's 1851 newspaper article. It also seems as though
Mr. Cherry had both Perrin and Bierce's accounts when
drawing up his draft of the story. It appears that the story kept adding more
and more details as the years went on.
"All but the
Pennsylvania Gazette article would be considered secondary sources
and require a great deal of interpretation, but should help students of
local history understand where on earth this story originated
- mostly wild imaginations. There is an extraordinary Indian captive
account in the PA Gazette about the family of Charles Stewart from the
same area where Mary was taken, but it happened in Nov. 1755 and Mary
was taken in May 1758. This fact further suggest all these stories
originated with Bierce."
"The
Bierce account is the closest thing we've got to "history" but even
that one requires a lot of interpretation.
All in all, the family doesn't
recognize the Cuyahoga Town or this area for references in any
of their family histories. They only know of the place where
Mary was taken by Bouquet at the Muskingum. They also say she
was captured at Penn's Creek, which is a long way from the Big
Cove area of
Conegochieg, Cumberland County, PA where almost all the
captures took place. I've been unable to locate any references
to any hostile Indian actions in the Penn Creek area in 1758
or a few years before or after". -
Michael Cohill
The Pennsylvania Gazette
October 11, 1764
Taken by the Indians, from
Cumberland County, May 21st,
1758, a certain Mary Campbell, then in her 10th Year, red
haired, and much freckled. Her Father hearing that she is now
at Albany, and being unable to go so far, begs that she may,
by all good People, be helped on her Way to him, as he, and
her aged Mother, are very desirous of seeing her.
Early
Scenes in Ohio
By
L.V. Bierce, 1851
Summit County
Beacon, November 8, 1851, 1:7
ABJ Microfilm
Series
University of
Akron, L.V. Bierce Library
-----
In 1759
Dugald Campbell, a Highland Scotchman of the
Campbell Clan was living in Tuscarora Valley
on the bank Canncoquin Creek, in Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania. In the same house with
Campbell resided a family by the name of
Stuart - consisting of the man, his wife and
several children - one of which was an infant.
Campbell had
a daughter, Mary, a black-eyed, lovely little
child of seven summers. Mrs. Stuart left home
one day to visit a neighbor’s entrusting her
children to the care of Mary Campbell. On her
return and when near the house, she heard the
children screaming and at that instant a party
of Delaware Indians came out of the house with
all the children, including her infant and
Mary Campbell, prisoners. They seized Mrs.
Stuart and added her to the number of captives
and then started for their camp on the
Catanions in what is now Armstrong County.
Soon becoming tired of the infant, they dashed
out its brains in presence of its mother. Mrs.
Stuart also had a little boy about seven years
old, who was either unable to walk or refused
to do so and the Indians carried him for three
days on their backs. On the third day the
Indian who had him on his back, fell behind
the company, but soon came up without the
child, but with a little white scalp hanging
to his belt. Mrs. Stuart recognizing the curly
locks of her little Sam, the Indian said “Hoo!
Otter skin.”
Mrs. Stuart and
the rest of her children, remained prisoners
until the Treaty of the Muskingum, by Bradstreet
and Bouquet in 1763, when they were given up.
Mary Campbell was adopted by
Netawatwees, head
Chief of the Turtle band of the Delawares, who,
in 1718, signed the Treaty of Conestoga. From
the time of her adoption by Netawatwees, Mary
was treated with great kindness and shared
equally in the affections of her adopted parents
with the other children.
The following year
Netawatwees, with his band, left Pennsylvania and removed to
the big falls of the Cuyahoga, just below what is now the
village of Cuyahoga Falls, in Summit County, Ohio. Mary
Campbell and other prisoners were taken along and became
residents of what is now Ohio. The Falls are a series of
rapids of about two miles in length, with three
perpendicular descents of twenty-two, eighteen and sixteen
feet over which the Cuyahoga river rushes.
At the foot
of these falls were two villages, one on the
south side belonging to the Iroquois, the one
on the north side belonging to the Delaware,
the river being the boundary between their
nations.
Soon after the
removal of Netawatwees to the Fall of the
Cuyahoga, the Indians made another incursion
into Pennsylvania, and murdered a number of
people, and took many prisoners at Tulpehauken,
in what is now Bercks County. Among the
prisoners was a Dutch woman, who was taken to
the Falls of Cuyahoga. A council was then called
to decide on the fate of the prisoners. They
gave the Dutch woman the choice to marry one of
three Indians who where willing to marry her, or
be killed. One of the three was the murderer of
her husband, one a miserable ugly Indian and the
third was the adopted uncle of Mary Campbell.
She chose the uncle of Mary, to whom she was
married and with whom she lived till the Treaty
of 1763. They had four children and as by the
Treaty, all persons having white blood were to
be given up, her husband became almost frantic
at the thought of a separation. Gladly would he
have abandoned his savage life and returned with
them; but such was the hostility of the whites
toward them that he was advised that his life
would be the price of doing so. His wife finally
consented to divide the children - she taking
two and leaving two.
While Mary was
living at the Falls honey bees first made their
appearance among the Indians. The Indians were
much frightened as they said bees were the
forerunners of the pale faces.
The reason the
Indians did not fight Bradstreet and Bouquet,
was Bouquet had sent a man by the name of Owen
to carry dispatches to Bradstreet, but he was
captured with his dispatches by the Indians. The
dispatches, which the adopted uncle of Mary
Campbell could read, showed the strength of the
whites to be superior to that of the Indians,
that they decided to treat, and not fight.
Netawatwees refused to attend the Treaty, but
attempted to escape. He was intercepted by
Bouquets Indian spies and brought before Col.
Bouquet, who deposed him from his Chieftainship
and put another in his stead. No sooner,
however, were the whites gone than the Delaware
reinstated him, and he held his office till
1776, when he died at Pittsburgh.
While Mary
resided at the Falls a pappoose was killed in a
mysterious manner. Suspicion rested on an old
squaw, but there was not sufficient proof
against her to convict. - Soon after a squaw was
murdered while at work in a cornfield a little
below the present village of Cuyahoga Falls, on
the north side of the river.
After being a
prisoner seven years, Mary Campbell was
surrendered up at the Treaty of Muskingum in
1763 and taken home. In 1771 she was married to
Joseph Wilford of Cumberland County, Pa. father
of the Rev. Samuel and grandfather a Joseph
Wilford Esq., lately a Member of the Legislate
of Ohio, from Green Township, Wayne County,
Ohio, where they now reside.
History of Summit County, with an
outline sketch of Ohio.
Ed. by William Henry Perrin
Publish Chicago, Baskin &
Battey, 1881
During the border wars of the last half of the last century, the
Indian villages, in what is now Summit County, were actively
engaged. They sent numerous small bands to Western Pennsylvania
to massacre the white pioneers in the border, and destroy their
habitations. It is extremely probable that some of the borderers
who were captured on these expeditions were tortured to death at
the villages in Summit County. Perhaps these spots, now so quite
and peaceful, once echoed with the frenzied death-cries of white
men, while around, on every hand, circled the leaping and
exulting savages, tearing up with hot iron the bleeding flesh of
the despairing sufferers, and filling the air with their
dreadful yells of revenge. Here the dusky savages, decked in the
gaudy ornaments of border war, invoked the favor of their god
before descending like death upon the defenseless settlements.
Here could be heard their wild chants - “Ne-gau niu-ne gau
nissau - Kitchi-mau-li-sau-negau nissau” (I will kill - I will
kill - The white man - I will kill) before they started on those
expeditions, of which we read in histories. In 1759, there lived
in Cumberland County Penn., a family named Campbell, consisting
of the father and a bright girl, about seven years old, named
Mary. Residing in the same house was another family named
Stuart, consisting of the husband and wife and four or five
children, one of those being an infant. One day, when the men
were absent, Mrs. Stuart left her children in charge of the
little girl Mary, and when a mile or two distant to the house of
a neighbor. In her absence, a small band of Delaware Indians
took possession of the cabin, and made all the children
prisoners, much to the consternation of little Mary, who was old
enough to know some awful calamity was pending. The Indians,
knowing that the adult members of the family were not far away,
made preparations to receive them. As Mrs. Stuart, on her
return, approached the house, she heard the children screaming,
and hurried forward, but was instantly made prisoner by the
savages, who then thought it best not to wait the return of the
men, but, with their prisoner, started for their camp in
Armstrong County. They soon became tired of carrying the infant,
which was fretful, and one of them finally took it, and in the
presence of its shrieking mother, dashed its brains out against
a tree, and cast its quivering body in the bushes. The Indians
pushed on rapidly, urging their weary and agonized prisoners to
their best pace, and carrying those that finally gave out. A
little boy about seven years old, named Sammy, was carried upon
the back of one of the Indians until the latter was tired. On
the third day, this Indians fell behind the others, and when he
again appeared, the little boy was missing while at his belt
Mrs. Stuart recognized the curly locks of her little Sammy. The
poor mother and her children were hurried on until at last weary
and footsore, they reached the Indian village. Here they were
soon separated, and one or more of them was adopted by the
Indians. The following year, Netawatwees, the chief of this
band, removed with his followers and prisoners to their village
at the “Big Falls” of the Cuyahoga, now in Summit County, Ohio.
Mary had been adopted by the chief, and was treated with uniform
kindness, occupying a position of equality with the Indian
children. Here the prisoners remained until 1764, when they were
delivered to Col. Bouquet, at his fort in Tuscarawas County, and
soon afterward were returned to their friends in Pennsylvania.
It is very probable that other white prisoners from the Indian
villages in Summit County were delivered up at this treaty.
Col. Bouquet had come out with an army of 1,500 men. The
appearance of this force awed the Indians, and they sued for
peace in the most abject manner, delivering up at the same time,
some 300 white captives. Fathers, brothers and husbands Had
come out in hopes of finding their lost friends, and when the
captives were given up the scene beggars description. “There
were seen,” says a writer in the Historical Record, “fathers and
mothers recognizing and clasping their once captive little ones;
husbands hung around newly-recovered wives; brothers and sisters
met after long separation, scarcely able to speak the same
language , or to realize that they were children of the same
parents! In the interviews, there was inexpressible joy and
rapture; while, in some cases, feelings of a very different
character were manifested by looks of language. Many were flying
from place to place, making eager inquiries after relatives not
found, trembling to receive answers to their questions,
distracted with doubts, hopes and fears; distressed and grieved
on obtaining no information about the friends they sought, and,
in some cases, petrified into living monuments of horror and woe
on learning their unhappy fate.” “In many cases,” Albach
Says, “strong attachments had grown up between the savages and
their captives, so that they were reluctantly surrendered, some
even not without tears, accompanied with some token of
remembrance.” The girl, Mary Campbell, and Mrs. Stuart and her
children, were the first white persons known to have lived in
what is now Summit County.
The Portage Path, by P.
P. Cherry
Cherry,
Peter Peterson, 1848‑ ??
Akron,
O., The Western Reserve Company, 1911
Cherry
was an amateur historian, very popular locally and very
creative with this history. He was 63 years old when the wrote
The Portage Path.
He was 75 when he wrote
The Western
Reserve and Early Ohio, And, he was 85 when the Cuyahoga Falls
D.A.R. asked him where he got his information about Mary
Campbell’s Cave.
The Story of Mary Campbell, The First White Female on the
Portage Path
Among
the prisoners delivered to Col. Bouquet at his headquarters
on the Tuscarawas river - in the fall of 1764, were a Mrs.
Stuart and her companion, little 12 year old Mary Campbell.
These so
far as is known, were the only white prisoners held by the
Indians in the territory now included in Summit County.
The
story of these lonely waifs so far from people of their own
color is but one of many in the annals of border warfare of
that day. The greatest number of white prisoners held at the
time by the Indians can best be estimated by the number
delivered to Bouquet but 25 miles below the south line of
the Western Reserve. The records show that he received 49
males, and 64 females belonging to Pennsylvania, with 32
males and 58 females belonging to Virginia, a total of 206;
plus 356 captives held in but a small portion of the state.
In the
fall of 1759, shortly after the signing of the Crogan treaty
of that year, the Delaware Chieftain and King of the Wolf
clans, Netawatwees and his warriors, after a prolonged pow-wow
in their village near Kittanning, struck the painted post
and in all the rude panoply of war-paint and feathers,
marched forth against the scattered white settlements on the
Susquehanna. Among the outlying lonely hamlets in this
beautiful valley was an isolated cabin occupied jointly by
two families; one by the name of Campbell consisting of the
father and daughter Mary, the other consisting of Mr.
Stuart, his wife and four children. For some time nothing
had arisen to alarm the lonely settlers, and in the morning
in question, the two men after eating their breakfast,
departed to their labor, not knowing that every motion was
shadowed by a savage and relentless foe.
After
the morning’s work was finished Mrs. Stuart who had an
errand at their nearest neighbors, several miles distant,
left her children in the care of little Mary Campbell and
departed on her journey. Some time after the woman’s
departure the Indians, much to the alarm of the children,
took possession of the cabin, waiting for the return of some
of the adults. Little Mary, although too young to understand
the full import of the proceeding, was very much frightened
and kept the huddled children near her in one corner of the
room. While waiting, the Indians ransacked the house and
made up their bags of plunder.
Upon the
return of Mrs. Stuart from her neighbors she heard the
screaming of her frightened children long before she reached
the cabins. Starting on a run she was horrified upon opening
the door to find the room filled with savages. She was
instantly made a prisoner, and hurried preparations were
immediately begun for departure. The younger children were
divided among their captors who made off with them and their
plunder on their backs; Mrs. Stuart carrying the infant which
was fretful and hard to keep quite. The savages convinced that
it retarded their flight, in spite of the woman’s entreaties,
took it from her arms, and in the presence of the shrinking
mother, dashed its brains out against a tree and threw its yet
quivering body into the bushes besides the path and increased
their speed, urging their tired, alarmed and grief stricken
captives to their best pace. Among the prisoners was Sammy
Stuart, a little 7 year old boy, who found it difficult to
keep up with the others, and was frequently carried on the
back of the Indian to whom he was assigned. On the third day
out from the cabin, the savage who was carrying little Sammy
dropped behind the others but soon reappeared alone, with a
fresh scalp hanging at his belt which the frantic mother
recognized as that of her little son. There was no time for
grief, as the savages were continually nagging their captives
to a greater speed by frequent use of blows and threats.
Arriving at the Indian village
the family was separated. All of the children, except Mary
were taken to other villages, and upon the expulsion of the
Delaware from Pennsylvania valleys in 1759-60, Netawatwees and
his tribe, with Mrs. Stuart and Mary Campbell, moved to the
Cuyahoga valley, settling at the Big Falls of the Cuyahoga,
Hopocan, as the Indians called it. Mary Campbell’s first home
in the Ohio country, was in the
AOld Maid’s Kitchen,
where the squaws and papooses
were temporarily domiciled, until the village could be built.
This spot, for a time long unknown had been the site of an
Indian village. Previous to 1650, the Eries, that little known
and very mysterious race, had a village here. After their
massacre and dispersion as a race by the combined Five
Nations, the Iroquois built a village on the south side of the
river; a little later, Netawatwees erected his village on the
north bank. As far back as is known, the plain of North Hill
was without signs of ancient forest growth. The entire plain,
as well as certain points of the Cuyahoga valley, was used by
the Indians as corn fields.
When first
seen by the whites the North Hill was a green oasis of a
waist-high, waving mass of variegated wild flowers, beautiful
beyond comparison, hemmed in and around by gigantic trees of
an ancient forest growth. It was here that little Mary
Campbell hoed corn 72 years before Akron became a village. She
had been adopted by the King of all Delaware tribes in the
Ohio country, and was kindly treated. She spent much of her
time at the northern terminus of Portage Path, fishing,
nutting, and gathering berries, and as far as is known was the
first white female ever on or near the historic path.
Not only
this, but as far as is known, Mrs. Stuart and Mary Campbell
were the first female captives with the limits of the Western
Reserve.
During the
winter of 1755, Col. James Smith was held captive at the falls
of Elyria. In making his escape he made his way through Medina
County and presumably along the Central Sandusky and Fort Pitt
Indian Trail, crossing the northern part of Portage Path at
Old Portage.
The year
that first saw Mrs. Stuart and Mary Campbell prisoner also
brought that great historical figure, Pontiac, prominently
before the American people. His camp, further down the
Cuyahoga, was known to the borders as Ponty’s Camp, and became
a great historical landmark. Major Rogers with 200 British
soldiers were at that time camped on the Cuyahoga.
In 1764,
Mary Campbell was turned over to Gen. Bouquet, on the
Tuscarawas, and was returned home where she was afterwards
married to Joseph Wilford, in the year 1771. She afterwards
resided in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, where she raised a
large family of children. Her son became one of the earliest
pioneers of Stark County, and his son, her grandchild,
afterwards became a member of the Ohio Legislature, from Wayne
County. He was named after his grandfather, Joseph Wilford.
|
Mary Campbell: Family Accounts
Other Links:
Metro Parks: Mary Campbell Cave
http://webtab.com/jennifer/visit11.htm
|